There is always so much going on in the blogosphere, and I love it – a constant ebb and flow of interaction, but the most recent activity, the ’100 comments challenge’ has shown me a whole new side to the blogosphere that quite frankly, I wish I hadn’t seen.
The Challenge was a fantastic idea – it really was! I mean who would not want the opportunity to meet and interact with 100 bloggers, potential JV partners, and future friends?! The majority of the contributors to the challenge took the opportunity with both hands. I personally took the opportunity with maybe one and half, but some people completely dropped it, in fact I doubt they even knew what they were holding in the first place!
I think you’re missing the point
The idea was to submit a post. 99 others would do the same and then everyone would attempt to get around to everyone else’s listed post and leave a comment. With this in mind, one would assume that you would submit the best post you ever wrote – or at least one that came close, right? Well, the number of times I chanced upon a post that simply said “I am in the 100 comments challenge and this is my post” was amazing! I think I can recall at least 10 where this was the case. Obvioulsy I DID NOT leave a comment. Sorry but I refuse to take part in that kind of valueless drivvle.
And the comments were not much better! Some people stopped by and commented saying “just commenting as part of the challenge”. OK so that is nice that you made it here and commented as such, but what value add is what again?!? How does that contribute any meaningful conversation to my post? Did you even read the post?!? Call me crazy but I think these people kind of missed the whole point to the activity?! (I actually got a comment saying “I am commenting for the challenge, now you HAVE to come and comment on mine, and do it now, challenge ends soon” GO AWAY! I am not even approving that comment btw!)
I am probably going to get frowned upon because I did not comment on all 99 blogs in the challenge, in fact I barely made it through 50, and then I only commented on maybe 25. The blog posts were either mindnumbing drivvle that actually made me stupider when I read them, or they were not in my niche. I refuse to comment if I have nothing to add, and saying I am part of the challenge is one stop short of SPAM!
Maybe I am being harsh, maybe not – but as far as I understood it the idea of the challenge was to meet new bloggers, build relationships and backlinks, and most importantly learn something!
Blogging up the garden path
The problem I see is that too much new blood is being led up the garden path.But it’s not a problem with the bloggers themselves. They are new to the online marketing world and they only know what their mentor is teaching them (or not as appears to be the case in a lot of instances). That’s another trend I am tending to notice. A lot of bloggers seem to be a student of one mentor or another and although this is usually a fantastic opportunity to learn from someone who knows what works, it can also lead to an inability to think for yourself. And THAT is what I am starting to notice in the blogosphere.
Do you know what the Blog you are doing?
If you have nothing of value to offer, then go out into the blogosphere and learn. There are some Marketers who I meet who have no idea about how any of this works, but they don’t pretend
otherwise either. I have watched them grow and now have a lot of respect for them as a blogger – so I am of course happy to help promote them and vice versa. On the flip side to this, when I first started online I was honest about what I did and did not know and the relationships I formed with some fairly high profile bloggers is still intact and is stronger than ever today. There is a mutual respect there that even I am surprised exists sometimes, but it just goes to show the power of being honest and accountable with your own knowledge and skillset.
But it’s not just about being accountable, in fact this has not really been the problem I have seen out there lately. The biggest issue I see is originality. Too many bloggers blogging the same thing on the same looking blog with the same ‘unique’ gift and the same Bio line, albeit a different name.
If you want to make money blogging then you need to be noticed! The problem with the above scenario is two fold. This new generation of bloggers are not taught how to really drive traffic, and even if they were – their blogs all look so similar that any potential visitors would assume they had been there before and simply leave.
How to never succeed blogging
This is the trend I am noticing online, and at least 25% of the blogs I visited for the 100 comments challenge were guilty of one or ALL of these.
- Blog for the money that you will make from it
- Promote the same products as your mentor recommends
- Promote products you don’t use or even have a clue about
- Use someone else’s gift to build your list but don’t even bother to at least go the PLR route and rebrand it.
- Use Adswaps and Giveaways to build this list of yours.
- Don’t build relationships with other bloggers. Comment occasionally sure – but don’ take it any further than this.
- Build relationships with your Adswap partners and NOT with your list.
- Drive traffic to your site using the same methods your ‘manual’ tells you about.
- Don’t teach yourself anything about link building, SEO, blogging, social media, or any type of traffic generation technique…ever.
- Listen to the teachings of one group or person exclusively
Pick up on the trend in that list? It’s all about thinking outside the square and finding your unique voice. There are heaps of posts you can read on finding your own voice, and of course you can find my blog for a gamut of information on link building and traffic generation, but really it all comes down to stepping outside of your comfort zone and LEARNING SOMETHING
Perhaps you could try to…
- Learn something relevant and applicable
- Contact at least one blogger requesting to submit a guest post
- Comment on 10 relevant blogs – leave an impact.
- Tweet – Share another 10 posts
- Write a post
- Leverage at least one piece of content (build a backlink)
- Be HONEST
- Be ORIGINAL
- Be YOURSELF
Who knows? Maybe you’ll find blogging is not so bad after all.
- What are your thoughts on the state of the blogosphere at present?
- Do you agree with my take on the ‘100 Comments Challenge’ participants?

















{ 169 comments… read them below or add one }
← Previous Comments
Hi Alex, I really don’t care what anyone thinks as long as I in my soul and being try to do the right thing. That blasts through everything. If I’m going to mess up I hope I mess up big because that is the best way to learn.
Yes in what ever is done there will always be those who stink. You can stink on purpose because you are a true stinker or you can stink because you are plainly new and doing your best. I commend those who do their best no matter what. For those who try to get by thinking they will get by easy that is their illusion. In the long run we all know that will lead to no where. So what the fuzz.
Most truly benefited from the 100 comment challenge that was born out of serendipity. Jacinta didn’t plan to do what resulted from an innocent comment on a forum.
The intent of the 100 comment challenge is good, therefore I intend to keep the list alive for those who want to get blog comments and learn. Learn being the key word. We all have the option on what to approve or delete. Common sense can weed out the good from the bad. Not just out of the 100 comment challenge list but, the internet as well, in fact the whole world.
My post about Clickbank has given me great insight thanks to the 100 comment challenge. I truly learned about affiliate marketing and the difference between selling an info product on it’s own vs putting it on Clickbank. My post was not a blog ploy it was an opportunity to learn and learn I did. Knowledge is power.
Alex your post makes sense and I hope some from the 100 comment challenge and the blogosphere will gain from your insightful imformation.
Terry Conti
Terry Conti´s last [type] ..Sell your ebook on its own or put it on Clickbank What do you think
Hi, Somehow i learn to write in other free blogging in which i can pick which topic i can elaborate or the one that i’m master.I don’t write if i don’t know anything about the topic.I started my first blog by
Putting my best interest post one,later on become two and more now.I will love to have more each days.Anyway good thing everybody is given a chance for free.To share useful ideas and take the challenge to everyone to start one for themselves.That is great deal for all.
I dont know who you think you’re, but youre just blowing smoke out your ear. Nothing you’re saying makes sense and its all a bunch of immature ranting. Should you want people to get behind your weblog, you should at the very least discover a small something about what youre talking about!
Twitter: buildrankprofit
September 17, 2010 at 6:58 PM
Is this a spam comment?!? It fits perfectly with this post – and it’s such a unique spam comment – if it is one, that I just have to approve it
Besides, it’s mildly entertaining actually
Twitter: mkronline
October 8, 2010 at 11:56 PM
I get a lot of these. It’s spam that uses a generic, angry response as a traffic driver. I once forgot to check my spam queue for a week, and had 30 comments across as many posts that were calling the “other commentators in this thread” idiots.
Posts that had no comments.
Twitter: buildrankprofit
October 9, 2010 at 9:23 PM
Hahahahaha, that’s gold!
Thanks for sharing MKR
Creating a blog that makes money, has traffic and a loyal reader base is hard… very hard, but many people are sucked into it because of how easy it appears. To me, I think u gotta focus on creating content you’re passionate and an expert in, building relationships with expert bloggers in your field, and building backlinks. Concentrate on those 3, and your chances of success goes up.
Henway@Candida´s last [type] ..How to make Medifast soup
Twitter: buildrankprofit
September 17, 2010 at 6:12 PM
Henway,
I don;t think I could have put it any better myself!
Thanks for your awesome comments my friend, and thanks for stopping by
Twitter: slcroft
September 22, 2010 at 10:26 PM
Hey Alex,
Been away for a month or so (computer died on me, funeral was very sad) so actually unable to complete the challenge anyway (I do still intend to visit the blogs tho, better late than never as they say) Needless to say got a lot of catching up to do.
Took me nearly all morning to read this post, you certainly know how to create a storm. I must admit, after reading the title I half expected to be greeted by the typical yellow book “dummies guide to………”
The concept of the challenge was good, as was what Jacinta tried to achieve. I don’t think the point had anything to do with just seeing how many comments you can get, on its own that means nothing. I feel what she was trying to achieve was to try and establish a readership for the blogs, raise the profiles, create relationships etc. This is perhaps where the challenge was lost on a few of the participants. All they could see was numbers and perhaps they didn’t give the value required. I must admit, I have never commented on a blog and expected one back in return, it is nice when that happens, but I don’t expect it.
I do believe that despite the criticism, Jacinta has come out of this very well. She might not feel like it and she might feel like she has gone 10 rounds with Tyson, but she has handled herself with dignity throughout yet still defending the participants to the hilt. I have got to take my hat off to her (if I wore one).
I agree, there are many blogs the same, mine included, that go on about the same thing, but I do believe in the value of the courses. Many good marketers have been borne out of both Alex’s & John’s courses.
I liken them to driving lessons. They teach you how to pass your test without particularly teaching you to drive (it is in the UK anyway), that only comes with experience. The same goes for the coaching courses. They give you the vital ingredients, then it is up to you to develop your own style and keep on learning as you go on.
Anyway, rambled on way too much
Cheers
Simon
hey, Alex
You have a nice post.Keep it up.
Blogging help boast the web traffic.It is one way of gaining backlinks.
If the comments is idealistic and real,and can add value to your topic then it is useful to both parties.
Twitter: buildrankprofit
October 4, 2010 at 10:41 PM
Hi Stealth!
Hello?
Oh, there you are (you are very elusive you know)
Thanks for the kudos and the comments my friend – glad you found the post helpful
Son-of-a-Pupster!
See? Now THIS is what I’m talking about! Real internet evolution at work…
The Hundred Comment Bone is connected to the Dummy Blogger Bone and just look at the skeleton crew you’ve assembled at the postmortem!
Brother, this was waaay better than watching a video. I was actually taking sides along the way!
When can we do this again?!
Keep a limber timber, Alex and have a grand day.
Barry
Barry from Saskatchewan´s last [type] ..Geometric Progression – Bam! Bam! Bam! One Friggin Thing Right After Another!
Twitter: buildrankprofit
October 9, 2010 at 9:36 PM
Barry!!
Hahahaha awesome comment brother!!
And can I just say that your analogy of the bones was downright GENIUS. Best I have seen in a while – and anyone who knows me knows how critical I am of a good analogy
Thanks so much for bringing your satirical eloquence to the table, definitely a most humerus reply
Just to let you know. I am enrolled in John Thornhill’s Masterclass. I am only on lesson two and have already learned alot I didn’t know about blogging. The site I used in the challenge wasn’t a proper blog. I participated hoping to learn new things, meet new people and get out of my comfort zone. I did something I had NO experience in. NONE. I am now learning about proper blogging and am confident I can be successful as I have found an excellent teacher to learn from.
One thing I HAVE learned is you are no teacher. Nor do you claim to be one. LOL You really haven’t encouraged me at all on my internet journey. I have been the target of condescending superiority towards the “dumb newbie blogger” because I tried something I have NO experience in! and that lack of experience shows. Rather that being patted on the back for giving the challenge a shot I have been called out as “dumb newbie” for trying to learn. I also started the challenge late because I had been working up the courage to even consider being involved. Not that you would know all this or even know me.
I am not a full time on the internet either. I have a day job. And a family. Not that you would know that info either or even care. I imagine your next comment will be to laugh and say you knew all that from my posting and site! LOL I am a NEWBIE in every sense of the word. Instead of taking the opportunity to reach out and encourage me, I have been SLAMMED, CALLED out and LAUGHED at because I had the courage to post a comment on your blog about MY perceptions and what I learned from participating. I repeat, I was NOT gently dropped here on earth with blogging know how in my brain. Were you? Who did you learn from? Were you encouraged with the same type of words you have “encouraged” me with? How long have you been blogging? How long until you created a successful blog? Or was the first one you ever created a blazing success? I do know that blogs change over time so it could be very possible that your successful blog of today COULD be the very same you started with but with change already integrated into it. Did you have a full time job and family when you started? Or did you start full time right away?
I have found teachers and friends who I believe I will learn a lot from. I have also found shiny examples of what I do not want to be associated with too. My motto “always be nice to people because you never know that kind of day they are having”. I apologize for my offenses. My purpose was/is not to be rude but to share my NEWBIE point of view. I wish you continued success.
Sincerely,
Fran T
Fran T´s last [type] ..Can you believe it is already October!
Twitter: mkronline
October 11, 2010 at 2:19 AM
There’s “trying and failing” and “failing to try.” As long as you’re doing the former, I don’t think the post was aimed at you. If your post wasn’t like the one in the third paragraph, your anger might be misdirected.
Twitter: buildrankprofit
October 12, 2010 at 1:54 AM
She can’t hear you MKR. Believe me brother (sister?) many have tried – but Fran only seems to hear the negative.
Nicely pointed out though
Twitter: buildrankprofit
October 12, 2010 at 1:52 AM
You know what Fran,
All I have done in every response to you AND in the original post – was give you a place to have your say and then encouraged your retorts – yet you seem to think that we are all ganging up on you.
I give up.
I have wanted to say this for a while, and I think with this latest rant I will.
I find it the most humourus and sweetest of ironies that your domain name is stopinflammation, yet all you ever seem is rather inflammed! LOL – perhaps you should go visit your own blog and learn to chillax for once
Sorry, I had to Fran – you kind of asked for it.
Have an awesome day – I mean that!
Thanks, Alex.
You have an awesome day too!
Fran
Fran T´s last [type] ..Can you believe it is already October!
Twitter: michaelpedzotti
October 12, 2010 at 9:24 PM
Hey Alex, it looks like you are participating in the 200 comment challenge
Michael Pedzotti@software tools for bloggers´s last [type] ..How many rivets in a Boeing 747
Twitter: buildrankprofit
October 15, 2010 at 2:38 AM
LOL!
Touche Michael
I’ve heard of NaNoWriMo where people write 50,000 words in 30 days in a relentless, unedited fit to unleash the muse of creativity.
But I’ve never heard of The Challenge or Blog-Commento-Wri-Mo-No-Making-a-Sense-o. That’s a first.
Gina Jennings´s last [type] ..Determining The Tone of Your Content
Twitter: buildrankprofit
December 26, 2010 at 11:43 PM
LOL HUH?
SO lost me there Gina – still chuckled though
I think the main point with creating a quality blog that most dummies get wrong, is that you have to actually be an expert on the topic you writing about, you can’t be a “me-too” blog, you have to hone in on a specific niche and dominate it with quality, unique, fresh, useful and interesting content every day. Not everyone can do this…
Twitter: buildrankprofit
January 27, 2011 at 6:36 PM
John mate,
I love the way you have so eloquently summarised a 1200 word post and 185 proceeding comments!
You got it perfectly, and in fact I wonder sometimes if I can do this!?!
Thanks for stopping by mate
Twitter: alanashwood
April 14, 2011 at 2:47 AM
Took some reading for these tired ole’ eyes, but thoroughly enjoyed the obsevations. I picked up on the original 100 Challenge after it finished, but went ahead all the same. I don’t think I’m bright enough to acheive 100 comments though, as my sites don’t have enough traffic yet. I still visit other bloggers regularly, and always leave a comment to at least appreciate the effort put into the work.
You were critical of people publishing similar content to others. Isn’t this inevitable?
There are only so many ways you can describe a golf ball, after all. Even I am guilty. However, if a newbie marketer finds my version, and gets value from it, I think that goes some way to justifying the article, don’t you?
Good stuff anyway Alaex.
Back soon
Alan
Alan Ashwood´s last [type] ..Reviewing the Review Sites – All is not always as it seems
Twitter: buildrankprofit
April 18, 2011 at 2:39 PM
Hey Alan,
ACtually at no stage was I critical of people producing similar content because as you said – it is inevitable.
I was being critical of those who comment and their idea of ‘value add’ being non existent.
Your point is right on to what I think, and if you can provide a new opinion and reach a new market then its not the same post anyway – so actually I think there are hundreds of ways you can explain a golfball.
Thanks for your comment Alan – this is the complete opposite of what I was putting shit on.
This comment provides value, asks the questions, engages the blog owner and makes me want to come and say hi back to continue the conversation, although how can anyone resist a URL like that?!
Thanks Alan, see you soon
Twitter: tipstrickzpark
May 17, 2011 at 5:46 PM
Awesome Thanks
I totally agreed for what you have said.
Everyone should,
HONEST
Hi there! I realize this is kind of off-topic however I had to ask. Does operating a well-established blog such as yours take a lot of work? I am completely new to operating a blog however I do write in my diary everyday. I’d like to start a blog so I can easily share my experience and feelings online. Please let me know if you have any suggestions or tips for brand new aspiring blog owners. Thankyou!
Augusta´s last [type] ..hair coloring ideas
Twitter: buildrankprofit
January 30, 2012 at 2:30 PM
Does a blog like this take a lot of work? SHIT YEAH… I mean “Why yes, yes it does”
← Previous Comments
{ 7 trackbacks }